Provisional research output.The underlying studies are being prepared for peer review and values may change. Not for investment or crediting decisions.
AfriERWReadiness Assessment
Country profile · Sub-Saharan Africa · Upper middle income

South Africa

Tier 1 of four readiness tiers, median rank 5 of 54. Indicator values show their source and evidence grade; X means no data.

Tier 1median rank 1 to 10; probability of this tier 81%
5 of 54median rank across uncertainty draws; 5 to 95% range 2 to 17; rank by the published index 4; P(top 10) 81%
2 of 3evidence domains with peer-reviewed ERW studies; credibility gate passed
2.84readiness index (0 to 5); lowest-scoring dimension: Soil and climate
5 of 7links of the chain of conditions met

Chain of conditions

5 of 7 links

The seven conditions a creditable removal needs. Not biophysically favourable. Binding link: C2 Soil and climate. Verification index 4.22 of 5.

How the chain works

Cropland

  • 164,732km² of cropland
  • 1,707km² acidic and warm-humid (favourable)
  • 138km² of it within 50 km of any documented deposit
  • 138km² verifiable (within 50 km of characterised rock, laboratory in reach)
  • 1,707km² where early monitoring must rely on soil analyses

Soil laboratory at home. Areas from the 1/24° grid of the integrated study.

Pathway

Pathways are computed for the countries that meet both resource conditions, C1 rock and C2 acidic cropland. South Africa does not meet C2 acidic cropland.

Readiness profile

Radar chart of the 7 dimension scores for South Africa against the median of all countries

Solid shape: South Africa. Dashed: median of the 54 countries.

At a glance

7 dimensions, 16 indicators

D1

Feedstock

5Evidence grade B
F1
Mafic rock near cropland
Value: 93.88 · Score: 5 of 5
Measure: % of cropland within 50 km of mafic rock (GLiM vb, pb, mtam, mtgr) (linear 0 to 50%)
Basis: % cropland within 50 km of mafic rock in the full-resolution GLiM (basic volcanic, basic plutonic, amphibolite, greenstone); 25 km 88.0%, 100 km 96.8%, with intermediate volcanics 94.7%; v1 (0.5 deg GLiM) 54.7%
Source: DS12b; DS18
Evidence grade B
F3
Mining and mine-residue footprint
Value: 3,594.6 · Score: 5 of 5
Measure: mapped mining area (Maus et al. v2) (quintiles)
Basis: mapped mining area 3594.6 km2, 1526 polygons [renamed: mining and mine-residue footprint; polygons are dominated by metal mines]
Source: Maus et al. global mining polygons v2 (area per country table)
Evidence grade B
D2

Soil and climate

0.789Evidence grade A
S1
Acidic cropland share
Value: 1.65 · Score: 0 of 5
Measure: % cropland with pH(H2O) < 5.5, 0 to 30 cm (linear 5 to 50%)
Basis: % cropland (CGLS-LC100 2019) with SoilGrids 0-30 cm pH(H2O) < 5.5 (5 km means); soil coverage 1.00
Source: DS01; DS18
Evidence grade A
S2
Weathering climate
Value: 17.15 · Score: 2 of 5
Measure: MAT 10 to 25 C and P/PET 0.2 to 1.0 on cropland (cell score, cropland-weighted)
Basis: cropland-weighted mean of cell scores: MAT 10-25 C and P/PET 0.2-1.0 (CHELSA V2.1 1981-2010); mean AI 0.46; WorldClim check score 1.959
Source: DS08; DS09; DS18
Evidence grade A
S4
Drainage and export pathway
Value: 82.8 · Score: 0.364 of 5
Measure: P minus AET (Fu-Budyko) (linear 50 to 500 mm)
Basis: cropland-weighted P - AET (Fu/Budyko, w = 2.6) from CHELSA bio12 and Penman PET
Source: DS08; DS09; DS18
Evidence grade B
D3

Agronomic fit

5Evidence grade B
A1
Cropland area
Value: 12,413,000 · Score: 5 of 5
Measure: cropland (log) (quintiles)
Basis: cropland 2024 (ha)
Source: FAOSTAT Land Use (RL), item Cropland, element Area
Evidence grade A
A2
Lime-responsive crop mix
Value: 0.65 · Score: 5 of 5
Measure: share of harvested area in lime-responsive crops (quintiles)
Basis: share of harvested area 2022-2024 mean in maize, dry beans, cassava, sugar cane, soya beans, groundnuts
Source: FAOSTAT Crops and livestock products (QCL), element Area harvested
Evidence grade B
A3
Fertiliser use
Value: 93.35 · Score: 5 of 5
Measure: N+P2O5+K2O per ha (quintiles)
Basis: N+P2O5+K2O kg/ha cropland, mean 2022-2024; agricultural lime not reported by FAOSTAT
Source: FAOSTAT Fertilizers by Nutrient (RFN), element Use per area of cropland
Evidence grade B
D4

Deployment and net-removal efficiency

2.46Evidence grade B
L1
Road access
Value: 326.2 · Score: 4 of 5
Measure: GRIP4 road density on cropland (quintiles)
Basis: cropland-weighted GRIP4 total road density (m/km2); quintiles across countries
Source: DS21; DS18
Evidence grade A
L2
National logistics performance
Value: 3.7 · Score: 3.38 of 5
Measure: LPI 2023 (2022 survey) (linear 1 to 5)
Basis: LPI 2022
Source: World Bank LPI via WDI LP.LPI.OVRL.XQ
Evidence grade B
E1
Grid carbon intensity
Value: 699 · Score: 0.009 of 5
Measure: g CO2 per kWh (linear 700 to 100)
Basis: gCO2/kWh 2025
Source: Ember Yearly Electricity Data (long format), Variable CO2 intensity
Evidence grade B
D5

MRV capacity

3.5Evidence grade C
M1
Accreditation infrastructure
Value: no data · Score: 5 of 5
Measure: ILAC MRA status (rubric 0/2/3/5)
Basis: SANAS national MRA signatory
Source: ILAC signatory print list and members-by-category, accessed 2026-10-28
Evidence grade A
M2
Soil laboratory network
Value: 2 · Score: 2 of 5
Measure: laboratories in AFRILAB or NENALAB meetings (2022) (count: 0 to 4 as counted, 5 if 6 or more)
Basis: laboratories listed (count only; names not redistributed)
Source: FAO AFRILAB-IV/22/Report Annex I; GLOSOLAN member update 2025
Evidence grade C
D6

Policy and markets

2.91Evidence grade A
P1
Article 6 engagement
Value: 2 · Score: 3.33 of 5
Measure: DNA, bilateral agreements, pipeline activity (0 to 3 rescaled)
Basis: DNA=1; bilateral agreements=0; PACM activities=17; ITMOs issued=0
Source: UNEP-CCC Article 6 Pipeline global data (last updated 13 Oct 2026); UNFCCC A6.4 DNA list (as at 1 Sep 2026)
Evidence grade A
P4
Governance quality
Value: -0.014 · Score: 2.49 of 5
Measure: WGI regulatory quality and rule of law (linear -2.5 to 2.5)
Basis: WGI RQ 2025, RL 2025
Source: World Bank Worldwide Governance Indicators (API source 3) GOV_WGI_RQ.EST and GOV_WGI_RL.EST
Evidence grade A
D7

Social licence

3.01Evidence grade A
T1
Tenure security
Value: 0.199 · Score: 3.01 of 5
Measure: share of adults insecure about main property (Prindex) (linear 0 to 50% (inverse))
Basis: weighted share of adults insecure about main property, round 2
Source: Prindex public microdata Rounds 1-2 (20240910), mainprop_security==0, PRINDEX_WT; linear 5 at 0% to 0 at >=50%
Evidence grade A

Feedstocks

44 deposits in the register, best evidence Tier 3. Published whole-rock analyses (GEOROC) exist near cropland, so the geochemistry of local rocks is partly known (median theoretical potential 350 kg CO2 per t).

Feedstock deposits for South Africa
DepositMaterial and rockTierEvidencePotential (kg CO2/t)ContaminantsAcidic cropland within 50 km (km²)
Amandelbult PGM tailings
ZAF-AMA
residue, mafic-ultramafic tailings3Evidence grade Cnot verifiednone screened0
Cullinan diamond mine historic kimberlite residues
ZAF-CUL
residue, kimberlite3Evidence grade Bnot verifiednone screened0
Impala PGM tailings (Rustenburg)
ZAF-IMP
residue, mafic-ultramafic tailings3Evidence grade Cnot verifiednone screened0
Kimberley (Diamond) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-KIMBER
residue, diamond tailings3Evidence grade Bnot verifiednone screened0
Mogalakwena PGM tailings (Northern Limb)
ZAF-MOG
residue, mafic-ultramafic tailings3Evidence grade Bnot verifiednone screened0
Nkomati Ni mine tailings (MMZ and PCMZ)
ZAF-NKO
residue, ultramafic tailings3Evidence grade Bnot verifiednone screened233.2
O'okiep Cu tailings
ZAF-OOK
residue, mafic tailings3Evidence grade Cnot verifiednone screened0
Palabora (Copper) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-PALABO
residue, copper tailings3Evidence grade Bnot verifiednone screened0
Rustenburg PGM tailings
ZAF-RUS
residue, mafic-ultramafic tailings3Evidence grade Cnot verifiednone screened0
Two Rivers PGM mine tailings (Eastern Limb)
ZAF-TWR
residue, mafic-ultramafic tailings3Evidence grade A228.4exceeds a soil limit within 10 applications16.6
Venetia diamond mine processed kimberlite (FRD/CRD)
ZAF-VEN
residue, kimberlite3Evidence grade Anot verifiedwithin limits0
Bushveld PGM by-products, operations not named (overburden, tailings, slag)
ZAF-BPG
residue, mafic-ultramafic tailings1Evidence grade Anot verifiednone screenedno data
Voorspoed diamond mine kimberlite residues
ZAF-VOO
residue, kimberlite1Evidence grade Bnot verifiednone screened0
Bakgatla (PGM) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-BAKGAT
residue, pgm tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0
Bakubung (PGM) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-BAKUBU
residue, pgm tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0
Bathopele (PGM) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-BATHOP
residue, pgm tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0
Bokoni (PGM) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-BOKONI
residue, pgm tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened14.1
Booysendal (PGM) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-BOOYSE
residue, pgm tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened41.1
Dwarsrivier (Chrome) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-DWARSR
residue, chrome tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened12.6
Eland (PGM) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-ELAND
residue, pgm tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0
Finsch (Diamond) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-FINSCH
residue, diamond tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0
Foskor (Phosphate) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-FOSKOR
residue, phosphate tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0
Helena (Chrome) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-HELENA
residue, chrome tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened24.4
Inyoni (Chrome) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-INYONI
residue, chrome tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0
Koffiefontein (Diamond) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-KOFFIE
residue, diamond tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0
Kroondal (PGM) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-KROOND
residue, pgm tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0
Machadodorp (Chrome) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-MACHAD
residue, chrome tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened140.5
Magareng (Chrome) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-MAGARE
residue, chrome tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened19.8
Marico (Chrome) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-MARICO
residue, chrome tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0
Marikana (PGM) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-MARIKA
residue, pgm tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0
Marula (PGM) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-MARULA
residue, pgm tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened1.2
Modikwa (PGM) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-MODIKW
residue, pgm tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0
Moeijelikj (Chrome) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-MOEIJE
residue, chrome tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened16
Mototolo (PGM) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-MOTOTO
residue, pgm tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened16.6
Pilanesberg (PGM) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-PILANE
residue, pgm tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0
Rasimone (PGM) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-RASIMO
residue, pgm tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0
Strathmore (Magnesite) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-STRATH
residue, magnesite tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened44.3
Styldrift (PGM) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-STYLDR
residue, pgm tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0
Tharisa (Chrome) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-THARIS
residue, chrome tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0
Thembelani (PGM) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-THEMBE
residue, pgm tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0
Thorncliffe (Chrome) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-THORNC
residue, chrome tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened17.3
Waterval (Chrome) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-WATERV
residue, chrome tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0
Windsor (Chrome) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-WINDSO
residue, chrome tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0
Zondereinde (PGM) tailings, Bullock 2023a
ZAF-B23-ZONDER
residue, pgm tailings0Evidence grade Dnot verifiednone screened0

Evidence indicators

Evidence is reported separately from readiness. Scores rise with peer-reviewed studies; grade B marks peer-reviewed evidence, C grey literature only.

F2
Feedstock characterisation (feedstock)
Score: 5 of 5
Rule: catalogue or >=3 peer-reviewed 5; 2: 4; 1: 3; grey only 2; none 0
Basis: 4 peer-reviewed, 1 grey characterisation record(s); national catalogue
Evidence grade B
F4
Contaminant screening (feedstock)
Score: 5 of 5
Rule: >=2 peer-reviewed 5; 1: 3; grey only 2; none 0
Basis: 3 peer-reviewed, 0 grey contaminant screen(s)
Evidence grade B
M3A
Field evidence with ERW-relevant rock (field)
Score: 0 of 5
Rule: >=3 peer-reviewed field 5; 2: 4; 1: 3; pot only 2; grey only 1; none 0
Basis: 0 peer-reviewed field, 0 peer-reviewed pot or incubation, 0 grey trial(s) with ERW-relevant rock; 0 trial(s) with other rock (not counted)
Evidence grade C
M3B
Measured CO2 removal (field)
Score: 5 of 5
Rule: >=2 peer-reviewed 5; 1: 4; grey only 2; none 0
Basis: 5 peer-reviewed in-country measurement(s) of CO2 removal (mine residues, not cropland)
Evidence grade B
T4
Social evidence (social)
Score: 0 of 5
Rule: >=2 peer-reviewed 5; 1: 4; grey only 2; none 0
Basis: no published public or farmer perception study of ERW found (searches of 28 Oct and 3 Nov)
Evidence grade C

Next evidence step

South Africa passes the strict evidence gate.

Evidence records counted

  • F2: characterisation, kimberlite, peer-reviewed 10.1016/j.apgeochem.2024.105986
  • F2: characterisation, PGM overburden, tailings, slag, peer-reviewed 10.1016/j.apgeochem.2026.106964
  • F2: characterisation, mafic-ultramafic tailings, peer-reviewed 10.1016/j.dib.2025.112125
  • F2: characterisation, mine tailings (national catalogue), peer-reviewed 10.1016/j.ijggc.2023.103844
  • F2: characterisation, mafic-ultramafic tailings, grey P2:OA1135
  • F4: contaminant screen, kimberlite, peer-reviewed 10.1016/j.apgeochem.2024.105986
  • F4: contaminant screen, mafic-ultramafic tailings, peer-reviewed 10.1016/j.dib.2025.112125
  • F4: contaminants, kimberlite, peer-reviewed 10.1093/annhyg/mer028
Show 12 more records
  • MINE: assessment, processed kimberlite, peer-reviewed 10.1007/s00710-018-0589-4
  • MINE: field sample, kimberlite residue, peer-reviewed; measured CO2 removal 10.1016/j.chemgeo.2022.121270
  • MINE: field, kimberlite coarse residue, peer-reviewed; measured CO2 removal 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2023.164853
  • MINE: field/lab, historic kimberlite residue, peer-reviewed; measured CO2 removal 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2024.177094
  • MINE: lab, kimberlite residue, peer-reviewed; measured CO2 removal 10.1186/s12932-023-00082-4
  • MINE: lab, processed kimberlite, peer-reviewed 10.3389/fclim.2022.913632
  • MINE: lab+field, kimberlite fine residue, peer-reviewed; measured CO2 removal 10.3389/fclim.2024.1345085
  • MINE: lab, kimberlite residue, conference abstract 10.46427/gold2020.2113
  • MINE: lab, kimberlite residue, conference abstract 10.46427/gold2020.2475
  • MINE: lab, kimberlite residue, conference abstract 10.7185/gold2021.4858
  • MINE: lab, kimberlite residue, conference abstract 10.7185/gold2021.5357
  • MINE: lab, kimberlite residue, thesis/other T:enhancedweatheringandcarbonationofkimberliteresiduesfromso

ERW studies

Show 5 more studies

Studies in the tropical evidence map

Accredited laboratories

ERW-relevant accredited laboratories in South Africa
LaboratoryScopeAccreditationStatusGrade
SGS BarbertonAssay (precious and base metals)company-stated currentEvidence grade A
SGS JohannesburgAssay (precious and base metals)company-stated currentEvidence grade A
Mintek Fire Assay and Reference MaterialsAssay (precious and base metals)SANAS T0042currentEvidence grade A
Anglo Corporate Services South Africa (Pty) Ltd, Mining and Technology Technical SolutionsMajor-element geochemistrySANAS T0051currentEvidence grade A
Ekurhuleni Water Care Company NPC (ERWAT) Laboratory ServicesEnvironmental soil testingSANAS T0082currentEvidence grade A
CSIR, Analytical Services StellenboschEnvironmental soil testingSANAS T0093currentEvidence grade A
Talbot Laboratories (Pty) LtdEnvironmental soil testingSANAS T0122currentEvidence grade A
UIS Analytical Services (Pty) LtdMajor-element geochemistrySANAS T0184currentEvidence grade A
ALS Chemex South Africa (Pty) Ltd, ALS MineralsMajor-element geochemistrySANAS T0387currentEvidence grade A
Waterlab (Pty) LtdEnvironmental soil testingSANAS T0391currentEvidence grade A
Environmental Pollution Laboratory (Pty) LtdEnvironmental soil testingSANAS T0419currentEvidence grade A
Omnia Group (Pty) Ltd, Chemtech LaboratoriesSoil chemistrySANAS T0466currentEvidence grade A
KL Analytical Services CC t/a LabserveSoil chemistrySANAS T0467currentEvidence grade A
Samancor Chrome Ltd, Eastern Chrome Mines Laboratory LtdMajor-element geochemistrySANAS T0503currentEvidence grade A
NMISA Inorganic AnalysisSoil chemistrySANAS T0555currentEvidence grade A
Alfred H Knight SA (Pty) LtdMajor-element geochemistrySANAS T0577currentEvidence grade A
Intertek Testing Services (Pty) LtdSoil chemistrySANAS T0627currentEvidence grade A
Dolphin Coast Environment and Laboratory Solutions (Pty) LtdEnvironmental soil testingSANAS T0631currentEvidence grade A
BEMLAB (PTY) LTDSoil chemistrySANAS T0654currentEvidence grade A
Aquatico Laboratories (Pty) LtdEnvironmental soil testingSANAS T0685currentEvidence grade A
Tharisa Minerals (Pty) LtdAssay (precious and base metals)SANAS T0699currentEvidence grade A
Xlab Earth Science (Pty) LtdSoil chemistrySANAS T0775currentEvidence grade A
NviroTek Laboratories (Pty) LtdSoil chemistrySANAS T0822currentEvidence grade A
SGS South Africa (Pty) LtdMajor-element geochemistrySANAS T0903currentEvidence grade A
Western Platinum LimitedAssay (precious and base metals)SANAS T0930currentEvidence grade A
FLSmidth Sampling PlantAssay (precious and base metals)SANAS T0958currentEvidence grade A
Intertek Genalysis South AfricaMajor-element geochemistrySANAS T0961currentEvidence grade A
Samancor Tubatse Alloys SmelterMajor-element geochemistrySANAS T1080currentEvidence grade A
Council for GeoscienceMajor-element geochemistrySANAS T1156currentEvidence grade A
Mintek Applied Chemical AnalysisMajor-element geochemistrySANAS T1184currentEvidence grade A

Measurement capacity

South Africa has accreditation coverage and a current accredited soil-chemistry laboratory: domestic measurement capacity.

  • Yes Accreditation coverage (SANAS national MRA signatory)
  • Yes Current accredited soil-chemistry laboratory
  • Yes Current accredited major-element laboratory
  • Yes Isometric in-country laboratory route

Article 6 and carbon markets

Article 6 status for South Africa
ItemStatus
Designated national authority (Article 6.4)Yes
Host-Party participation requirements publishedYes
Authorising body listed (implementation report)No
CARP initial report submittedNo
Bilateral Article 6.2 agreements0
PACM activities in the pipeline17
National carbon-market frameworkLevel 3 of 3: Act or regulation
Carbon Tax Act 2019 and Carbon Offsets Regulations; draft Article 6 Framework (2024), in force (domestic offsets); Article 6 framework draft
Article 6 institutional arrangements (P6)2 of 5 Proposed scale

Social licence in carbon-market law

  • Benefit sharing: None identified
  • Consent: Consultation or participation
  • Grievance mechanism: None identified

No carbon-specific benefit-sharing rule identified

Inglesi-Lotz et al. 2025 (Natural Justice/CEJA review) https://naturaljustice.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/CARBON-MARKETS-REPORT_Submitted_Natural-Justice.pdf

Legal provisions are not evidence that communities accept a project. All countries

What-if analysis

Illustrative

Move a dimension score to see how the readiness index and rank would respond, with all other countries held at their published values. This is a sensitivity tool, not a forecast.

Tip: the left and right arrow keys move to the previous and next country.