Provisional research output.The underlying studies are being prepared for peer review and values may change. Not for investment or crediting decisions.
AfriERWReadiness Assessment

Market activity and the evidence base

Companies have reported enhanced rock weathering operations, credit sales or offtake agreements in several African countries. This page compares where that activity is reported with the evidence and institutions of each country.

7countries with reported market activity (company or press reports, grade C)
4of the 7 have no peer-reviewed field evidence (C4)
3have no characterised feedstock (C3)
0.89AUC of the chain score without field evidence (C4), against 0.77 for the readiness index

Countries with reported activity

Reports were found by a dated scan of registries and company and press sources; none had been confirmed on a crediting registry at the time of the scan, so every report is graded C. Companies are not named here; the sources are linked. Activity: 1 to 3, from a reported pilot to credit sales or offtake agreements.

Countries with reported ERW market activity
CountryActivityGradeC3C4C5C6Links metReport
Cameroon2Evidence grade CC3 Characterised feedstock metC4 Field evidence metC5 Measurement not metC6 Crediting and authorisation not met4source
Ghana2Evidence grade CC3 Characterised feedstock metC4 Field evidence metC5 Measurement metC6 Crediting and authorisation met5source
Kenya3Evidence grade CC3 Characterised feedstock metC4 Field evidence not met, binding linkC5 Measurement metC6 Crediting and authorisation met5source
Nigeria2Evidence grade CC3 Characterised feedstock metC4 Field evidence metC5 Measurement metC6 Crediting and authorisation met5source
Tanzania2Evidence grade CC3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding linkC4 Field evidence not metC5 Measurement metC6 Crediting and authorisation met4source
Uganda3Evidence grade CC3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding linkC4 Field evidence not metC5 Measurement not metC6 Crediting and authorisation met3source
Zambia2Evidence grade CC3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding linkC4 Field evidence not metC5 Measurement metC6 Crediting and authorisation met5source

Which conditions does market activity need?

Necessary condition analysis: the share of the range of each link score that lies below the lowest score among countries with market activity (effect size d). Asterisk: permutation P below 0.05.

Necessary condition effect size d of each link score for ERW market activity0.00.10.20.30.40.5C1 Rock0.23C2 Soil and climate0.24*C3 Characterised feedstock0.00C4 Field evidence0.00C5 Measurement0.30*C6 Crediting and authorisation0.36*C7 Social licence0.11*
Values
Necessary condition effect sizes
LinkdP (permutation)
C1 Rock0.230.247
C2 Soil and climate0.240.013
C3 Characterised feedstock0.001.000
C4 Field evidence0.001.000
C5 Measurement0.300.041
C6 Crediting and authorisation0.360.021
C7 Social licence0.110.007

What predicts market activity?

Area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) for market activity, with bootstrap 95% intervals; 0.5 is no discrimination. The chain score excludes field evidence to avoid circularity.

Area under the curve for ERW market activity with 95% intervals0.30.50.70.91.0Chain score without C40.89Verification index0.84Readiness index0.77Biophysical sub-index0.64
Values
AUC for market activity
ScoreAUC95% interval
Chain score without C40.890.79 to 0.97
Verification index0.840.67 to 0.97
Readiness index0.770.61 to 0.90
Biophysical sub-index0.640.47 to 0.81

Market activity occurs in countries with no characterised feedstock and no field evidence (d = 0 for both) but not below a minimum level of measurement capacity and crediting institutions. With 7 countries the results are indicative only. They are consistent with market activity following crediting institutions rather than local evidence that the removals occur.