Pathways to a creditable removal
For each of the 17 biophysically favourable countries, every failed core link is matched to the action that would close it. Most of the actions fall to geological surveys, research institutions, accreditation bodies and governments. The five countries closest to the chain hold 83% of the favourable cropland of these countries.
The countries closest to the chain
Madagascar lacks only field evidence. DR Congo, Tanzania and Zambia need characterised feedstock and field evidence; Cameroon, which has both, needs laboratory access and a carbon-market framework. Three of the five also have reported market activity, so closing these gaps there would also support the integrity of any credits issued.
Characterisation alone has limited reach. Characterising every documented deposit would raise verifiable cropland only from 1,595 to 1,956 km², and giving every country laboratory access as well would raise it to 3,904 km², because most favourable cropland lies far from any documented deposit. New sampling of mapped mafic units near acidic cropland is as important as analysing known deposits.
One laboratory. Of the 8 favourable countries that fail the measurement link, 5 could use an accredited soil laboratory in a regional partner state once they have accreditation coverage; the other three share membership of ECCAS, so one new accredited laboratory in any of its 11 member states would serve all three.
Costs
Costs are not attached to the actions, because comparable cost data were not available. The counts are numbers of actions, not their size.
The research needed to close the evidence gaps is set out in the research gap register; the studies each country needs to pass the evidence gates are on the field evidence page.
Actions by actor
| Link | Action | Lead actors | Scale |
|---|---|---|---|
| C3 Characterised feedstock met | Characterise documented deposits to Tier 2 or above, with contaminant and asbestos screening | Geological surveys, universities, funders | 3 deposits |
| C3 Characterised feedstock met | Sample and characterise mapped mafic units near acidic cropland where no deposit is documented | Geological surveys, universities | 12 countries |
| C4 Field evidence met | Public reference field sites on acidic soils, measuring agronomic and removal outcomes for several years with soil-based methods | Research institutions, funders, project developers | 16 countries |
| C5 Measurement met | Accreditation coverage through a national or regional body | Accreditation bodies, regional economic communities | 7 countries |
| C5 Measurement met | One new accredited soil laboratory in the Economic Community of Central African States | Regional economic communities, funders, standard setters | 1 laboratory serving Cameroon, Equatorial Guinea and São Tomé and Príncipe |
| C6 Crediting and authorisation met | A carbon-market policy or law stating whether, and under which laboratory standard, ERW removals can be authorised | Host governments | 11 countries |
| C7 Social licence met | Benefit-sharing, consent and grievance provisions in carbon-market law | Host governments, legislatures | 15 countries |
Measurement and crediting steps for standard setters, accreditation bodies, buyers and registries
| Actor | Action |
|---|---|
| Host governments (Article 6 authorities, ministries) | State whether ERW removals can be authorised and correspondingly adjusted, and which laboratory standard applies |
| Accreditation bodies (national, SADCAS, SOAC-WAAS) | Extend accredited scopes of existing agricultural and geological laboratories to soil cations, total elements and inorganic carbon |
| Laboratories and regional networks | Offer accredited analysis and validation to partner states; join proficiency-testing schemes |
| Standard setters (Isometric, Puro.earth, Rainbow, CSI, Article 6.4 Supervisory Body) | Recognise regional reference laboratories and name acceptable proficiency-testing schemes and reference materials; state host-country requirements |
| Funders and development partners | Fund a few openly reported reference sites on acidic tropical cropland that quantify removal |
| Buyers and registries | Ask for laboratory accreditation and host-country status in project documentation |
Actions by country
Dots mark the action needed for each failed link; the number of core links missing is in brackets. Countries are ordered by the number of links missing, then by favourable cropland, shown as bars. Select an action to show only the countries that need it.
| Country | C3Documented deposit | C3New unit | C4Field site | C5Accreditation | C5Regional laboratory | C6Policy or law | C7Provisions | Favourable cropland (km²) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Madagascar (1) | needed | needed | 20,068 | |||||
| Tanzania (2) | needed | needed | needed | 51,249 | ||||
| DR Congo (2) | needed | needed | 26,886 | |||||
| Zambia (2) | needed | needed | 11,275 | |||||
| Cameroon (2) | needed | needed | needed | 3,457 | ||||
| Angola (3) | needed | needed | needed | needed | 9,606 | |||
| Rwanda (3) | needed | needed | needed | needed | 2,809 | |||
| Guinea-Bissau (3) | needed | needed | needed | needed | 1,373 | |||
| Eswatini (3) | needed | needed | needed | needed | 813 | |||
| Liberia (3) | needed | needed | needed | needed | 221 | |||
| Mauritius (3) | needed | needed | needed | needed | 185 | |||
| Comoros (3) | needed | needed | needed | needed | 59 | |||
| Burundi (4) | needed | needed | needed | needed | needed | 5,037 | ||
| Guinea (4) | needed | needed | needed | needed | needed | 1,809 | ||
| Sierra Leone (4) | needed | needed | needed | needed | needed | 1,336 | ||
| Equatorial Guinea (4) | needed | needed | needed | needed | needed | needed | 98 | |
| São Tomé and Príncipe (4) | needed | needed | needed | needed | needed | needed | 7 | |
| Total actions | 3 | 12 | 16 | 7 | 3 | 11 | 15 |