The chain of conditions for a creditable removal
Rock spread on farmland yields a creditable removal only if every condition holds: rock within reach, suitable soil and climate, characterised feedstock, field evidence, accredited measurement, crediting and authorisation, and social licence. This assessment asks which condition fails first; the readiness index asks where conditions favour deployment.
Link by link
Countries meeting each link among all 54 states and among the 17 biophysically favourable states (those meeting C1 and C2). The binding link is the failed link with the lowest score on a common 0 to 5 scale; the first failing link follows the fixed order C1 to C7. The six core links are C1 to C6; C7 is reported separately because its evidence base is thinnest.
| Link | Main condition | All 54 | Favourable (17) | Binding link | First failing link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| C1 Rock met Rock Resource | Mafic rock mapped within 50 km of cropland, or a documented feedstock deposit | 48 | 17 | 1 | 6 |
| C2 Soil and climate met Soil and climate Resource | At least 10% of cropland with topsoil pH below 5.5 | 20 | 17 | 3 | 31 |
| C3 Characterised feedstock met Characterised feedstock Resource | A deposit with measured CaO and MgO (characterisation Tier 2 or above) | 7 | 2 | 38 | 15 |
| C4 Field evidence met Field evidence Evidence | A peer-reviewed field or pot trial with ERW rock, or a measured removal, in the country | 5 | 1 | 10 | 1 |
| C5 Measurement met Measurement Verification | Accreditation coverage and an accredited soil-chemistry laboratory at home or in a regional partner state | 32 | 9 | 0 | 1 |
| C6 Crediting and authorisation met Crediting and authorisation Verification | An Article 6.4 national authority and a carbon-market policy or legal instrument in force | 22 | 6 | 0 | 0 |
| C7 Social licence met Social licence Legitimacy | Benefit-sharing and community consent or participation provisions in force | 6 | 2 | 2 | 0 |
Link codes C1 to C7 correspond to L1 to L7 in the integrated study. They are renamed here because the readiness index already uses L1 and L2 for its logistics indicators.
Countries along the chain
| Country | Tier | C1 | C2 | C3 | C4 | C5 | C6 | C7 | Links met | Binding link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DR Congo favourable | Tier 1 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met | C4 Field evidence not met, binding link | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence met | 5 | C4 Field evidence |
| Ghana | Tier 2 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met, binding link | C3 Characterised feedstock met | C4 Field evidence met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence not met | 5 | C2 Soil and climate |
| Kenya | Tier 2 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock met | C4 Field evidence not met, binding link | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence met | 5 | C4 Field evidence |
| Madagascar favourable | Tier 1 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock met | C4 Field evidence not met, binding link | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence not met | 5 | C4 Field evidence |
| Nigeria | Tier 2 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock met | C4 Field evidence met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence not met, binding link | 5 | C7 Social licence |
| South Africa | Tier 1 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met, binding link | C3 Characterised feedstock met | C4 Field evidence met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence not met | 5 | C2 Soil and climate |
| Zambia favourable | Tier 1 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence met | 5 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Cameroon favourable | Tier 1 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock met | C4 Field evidence met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met, binding link | 4 | C7 Social licence |
| Egypt | Tier 2 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met, binding link | C3 Characterised feedstock not met | C4 Field evidence met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence not met | 4 | C2 Soil and climate |
| Ethiopia | Tier 1 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence met | 4 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Malawi | Tier 1 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock met | C4 Field evidence not met, binding link | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence not met | 4 | C4 Field evidence |
| Tanzania favourable | Tier 2 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence not met | 4 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Zimbabwe | Tier 2 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence met | 4 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Angola favourable | Tier 2 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met | C4 Field evidence not met, binding link | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 3 | C4 Field evidence |
| Comoros favourable | Tier 3 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 3 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Côte d’Ivoire | Tier 2 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence not met | 3 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Eswatini favourable | Tier 2 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 3 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Guinea-Bissau favourable | Tier 3 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 3 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Liberia favourable | Tier 3 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence not met | 3 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Mauritius favourable | Tier 1 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met | C4 Field evidence not met, binding link | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 3 | C4 Field evidence |
| Rwanda favourable | Tier 2 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence not met | 3 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Senegal | Tier 2 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met | C4 Field evidence not met, binding link | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence not met | 3 | C4 Field evidence |
| Uganda | Tier 3 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence met | 3 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Algeria | Tier 4 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Benin | Tier 3 | C1 Rock not met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Botswana | Tier 2 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met | C4 Field evidence not met, binding link | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C4 Field evidence |
| Burkina Faso | Tier 3 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Burundi favourable | Tier 4 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Central African Republic | Tier 4 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Djibouti | Tier 3 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Equatorial Guinea favourable | Tier 4 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Gabon | Tier 2 | C1 Rock not met | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Guinea favourable | Tier 2 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Lesotho | Tier 2 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Mali | Tier 3 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Morocco | Tier 2 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met | C4 Field evidence not met, binding link | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C4 Field evidence |
| Mozambique | Tier 2 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Namibia | Tier 3 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met | C4 Field evidence not met, binding link | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C4 Field evidence |
| Niger | Tier 4 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Seychelles | Tier 3 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Sierra Leone favourable | Tier 3 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| São Tomé and Príncipe favourable | Tier 3 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Togo | Tier 3 | C1 Rock not met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation met | C7 Social licence not met | 2 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Cabo Verde | Tier 4 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 1 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Chad | Tier 4 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 1 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Eritrea | Tier 4 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 1 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Libya | Tier 4 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 1 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Mauritania | Tier 4 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 1 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Republic of the Congo | Tier 4 | C1 Rock not met | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 1 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Somalia | Tier 4 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 1 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| South Sudan | Tier 4 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 1 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| Sudan | Tier 3 | C1 Rock met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 1 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
| The Gambia | Tier 4 | C1 Rock not met, binding link | C2 Soil and climate met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement not met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 1 | C1 Rock |
| Tunisia | Tier 2 | C1 Rock not met | C2 Soil and climate not met | C3 Characterised feedstock not met, binding link | C4 Field evidence not met | C5 Measurement met | C6 Crediting and authorisation not met | C7 Social licence not met | 1 | C3 Characterised feedstock |
Filled: link met. Outlined: not met. Ringed: the binding link. Distribution of links met: 1 link 11 countries, 2 links 20 countries, 3 links 10 countries, 4 links 6 countries, 5 links 7 countries.
Where removals could be verified
Favourable cropland is acidic (topsoil pH below 5.5) and lies in a warm, humid weathering climate, mapped on a 1/24 degree grid. It is verifiable where it lies within 50 km of rock characterised to Tier 2 or above, in a country with an accredited soil laboratory at home or in a regional partner state.
Cropland in numbers
- 176,887km² of favourable cropland in the 54 countries
- 1,595km² verifiable (0.9%); verifiable cells are enlarged on the map
- 99.9%of acidic cropland would retain the alkalinity of a 20 t/ha basalt application, so monitoring in the early years would rely on soil analyses
- 14%of the favourable cropland that needs soil-based monitoring has no accredited soil laboratory in reach
Points: deposits characterised to Tier 2 or above. Grid classes are drawn at the nearest cell, without smoothing. Select a country to open its profile.
Threshold explorer
Change the threshold of any link to see which countries would pass. Each combination of settings is one of the 864 variants of the study's sensitivity analysis, and the explorer reproduces its results; the published settings are marked. The selection is kept in the page address.
The explorer needs JavaScript.
Countries meeting each link
Grey marks: the published thresholds.
Across all 864 variants, at most 2 countries (Cameroon and Nigeria) pass the six core links, in 40 variants and only under lenient definitions.
Two assessments of the same evidence
The readiness index is compensatory: strength in one dimension offsets weakness in another, so it describes where conditions favour deployment. The chain of conditions treats each condition as necessary: a removal cannot be credited if the feedstock is uncharacterised, however good the laboratories. It describes where creditable, accepted removals could be delivered.
The two assessments rank countries similarly (Spearman ρ = 0.80 between the readiness index and the number of links met), but they answer different questions: every one of the 8 countries in readiness Tier 1 fails at least two links. Among the 26 countries in Tiers 1 and 2, 22 fail on characterised feedstock or field evidence. The binding constraint is knowledge of the rock rather than its presence.
Readiness Tier 1 along the chain
- Ethiopia: 4 of 7 links; binding link C3 Characterised feedstock
- Mauritius: 3 of 7 links; binding link C4 Field evidence
- DR Congo: 5 of 7 links; binding link C4 Field evidence
- South Africa: 5 of 7 links; binding link C2 Soil and climate
- Madagascar: 5 of 7 links; binding link C4 Field evidence
- Cameroon: 4 of 7 links; binding link C7 Social licence
- Zambia: 5 of 7 links; binding link C3 Characterised feedstock
- Malawi: 4 of 7 links; binding link C4 Field evidence
Pre-specified hypotheses and results
| Expectation | Result | |
|---|---|---|
| H1 | Fewer than one in ten countries satisfy all six core links | Supported: 0 of 54 (95% confidence interval 0 to 6.6%). |
| H2a | Verification capacity is not positively associated with biophysical suitability | Not supported: Spearman ρ = 0.38 (95% CI 0.14 to 0.59), carried by agricultural scale; with soil and climate alone ρ = −0.04. |
| H2b | Less than 10% of favourable cropland is verifiable | Supported: 0.9% under the main definition and 0.16% under the strict one. |
| H3 | Among the top two readiness tiers, the binding link lies outside the resource domain in at least two thirds | Not supported: 42%, because characterised feedstock, classed as a resource link, is itself the most common binding link. |